Why Real Id Is Bad?

Introduction
The Real ID Act is a law passed by the U.S. Congress in 2005 that establishes new federal standards for state-issued driver’s licenses and identification cards. While the law was intended to improve national security, it has been met with criticism from a range of groups who argue that it is bad for privacy, civil liberties, and even public safety.

Privacy Concerns
One of the main reasons why the Real ID Act is viewed as bad is because of its potential impact on privacy. Under the law, states are required to collect and store a wealth of personal information about their residents, including their full legal name, date of birth, Social Security number, and proof of residency. This information will then be entered into a national database that will be accessible to federal agencies and law enforcement.

Critics argue that this database could be used to track individuals’ movements and activities, potentially infringing on their privacy rights. Additionally, there are concerns that the information could be vulnerable to hacking or data breaches, putting millions of people at risk of identity theft.

Civil Liberties Concerns
The Real ID Act has also been criticized for its potential impact on civil liberties. The law requires that states verify an individual’s immigration status before issuing them a driver’s license or identification card. This has led to concerns that the law could be used to discriminate against immigrants and minorities, who may be less likely to have the required documentation to obtain a Real ID-compliant card.

There are also concerns that the Real ID Act could be used to restrict access to certain services and benefits for those who do not have a Real ID-compliant card. For example, some states have indicated that they may require a Real ID-compliant card to access certain government buildings or board domestic flights.

Costs and Logistics
Another reason why the Real ID Act is viewed as bad is because of the costs and logistical challenges associated with implementing it. States are required to upgrade their driver’s license and identification card systems to meet the new federal standards, which can be costly and time-consuming. Additionally, there are concerns that some states may not be able to meet the federal deadlines for implementation, leading to confusion and chaos for travelers.

Public Safety Concerns
Ironically, some have argued that the Real ID Act is bad for public safety. For example, some groups have expressed concern that the law will discourage undocumented immigrants from obtaining a driver’s license or identification card, which could lead to more people driving without a license or insurance. Additionally, some have suggested that the law could make it more difficult for law enforcement to identify suspects or missing persons, as the new requirements may lead to delays in obtaining identification documents.

Conclusion
While the Real ID Act was intended to improve national security, it has been met with a range of concerns and criticisms from privacy advocates, civil liberties groups, and others. The law’s potential impact on privacy, civil liberties, and public safety, as well as the logistical challenges associated with implementing it, have led many to question whether the benefits of the Real ID Act outweigh its drawbacks.

Was this article helpful?
YesNo